My Indonesian friend Edder and I were coincidentally in Jakarta at the same time a few months before the 2024 Indonesian presidential elections. I had just finished a work project and had a day to kill. He had an entirely different mission in mind.
“So tomorrow is going to be a political rally for Anies. You know Anies?”
I nodded. “I don’t know too much about him though.”
“Anies is one of three candidates running for president. Well, I think he’s the best candidate so I want to see his political rally.”
“Oh. What time?”
“Well I don’t know for sure. Some of my other friends are going at 3:00 in the morning. So I was thinking I should leave at 5:00.”
“That is a disgusting time. What time does it actually start?”
“Anies is supposed to get there at 10:00 am.”
“And why would you leave at 5am?”
“Trust me, there will be a lot of people there. I should leave early.”
I am a night owl. I hate going to bed before 2:00 am and I hate waking up before 9:00 am. But this piqued my interest given the heightened political climate. “Can I come along?!”
Edder looked at me with disbelief. “You want to go? You can’t even vote!” He could not fathom why anyone would willingly descend into the hornet’s nest of Indonesian politics. Indeed, even he only joined out of perceived necessity.
“Penasaran saja! I’ve never been, you know? I think it’d be a learning experience!”
“Okay then. We need to sleep now so we can leave at 5:00 pm… am.”
We left Edder’s hotel and zipped along Jakarta’s streets at first light. Our destination was Jakarta International Stadium (a.k.a. JIS), Jakarta’s modern stadium with a seating capacity of 85,000. The sun had barely risen but Edder was already worried that we would not be able to enter Anies’ rally. I was too preoccupied mentally collecting myself. What little brain function I scraped together concluded that he worried unnecessarily. Then we hit traffic.
~4 Kilometers from JIS
Jakarta is no stranger to traffic congestion. The city is famous for its gridlock. Jakarta serves as the political, economic, entertainment, and fashion hub for the nation. Ask any Indonesian to describe Jakarta in three or four words, and they will say (generally in this order), “hot, packed (dense), congested (traffic), and dirty (polluted)”. Indonesians drive the sentiment home with a common saying: “Go to Jakarta to work. Go anywhere else to live.”
At the heart of our problem was (and still is) a lack of general infrastructure. Jakarta’s urban planners designed relatively few main roads with many smaller, branching feeder roads. What few signs and traffic lights exist are only along the main roads. Thus traffic going to and from the feeder roads is a constant stop-and-go affair. It is usually only directed by men and women who appoint themselves as traffic controllers and collect money while standing in front of cars.
Additionally, the streets were neither designed for large vehicles nor high capacity. Indonesia’s middle class has ballooned over the last decade. Their desire for cars & SUVs (in indonesian: “mobil”) have ballooned with it. Social status and mobil size are generally positively correlated - and in the East, status is everything.
Most importantly, the number one rule of traffic throughout Indonesia is…. there is no rule. Pedestrians cross wherever and whenever they want. Drivers will make their own lanes in order to jockey for position. Scooters and motorcycles alike alight onto the sidewalk when the street is not moving. I mentioned in The Inevitable Traffic Comparison that I felt safer in Indonesia than in America. Part of that is that drivers are hyper-aware because pedestrians and other drivers do as they damn well please. The other part is that traffic is slow enough that it’s hard to be fatally hit by the average vehicle.
Thus, Edder and I zipped along the main road to JIS on his moped (in Indonesian, “motor”). Until we did not. There motors and mobils proceeded at a crawl. We crept forward another half kilometer saturated with idling engine noise and exhaust fumes. It turned out that much of the center of said road was taken up by a growing caravan of humanity who were all supposedly now walking to JIS to support Anies. Hundreds of motor drivers had perpendicularly parked their bikes on both sides of the main road. We followed suit, of course. Illegality matters little if everyone else is doing it.
~3.5 kilometers
We gingerly stepped off Edder’s motor so as not to cause the adjacent motors to fall like dominoes. The human stream lazily flowed towards JIS. Whole families of Anies supporters walked alongside us, each family member clad in pro-Anies tees. Childrens’ laughter occasionally punctuated the gentle susurrus of chatter as they ran through the crowd. A solitary street preacher loudly extolled Anies’ virtues, the first “real president” in a long line of “fake presidents”.
Opportunistic entrepreneurs lined the street. Men carried snacks and signs for cold water. Ladies sold prepackaged food. Other vendors sold curiously incongruent items. Some vendors offered belts and sunglasses. Others displayed silicone cell-phone protectors. Several were hawking pro-Palestine flags, scarves, headscarves, and tees. The only notable absence from the vendor list was pro-Anies merchandise.
The entire affair felt like a cross between a peaceful demonstration march and a street festival. The only odd thing about it was its lack of intention. It was this way only because everyone was forced to walk starting at the 3.5 kilometer mark. I am not a lazy man, but I will gripe if I am forced to walk where I ought to be driving. I’m pretty sure Edder and the Indonesians present took the entire thing in stride far easier than I did. The number one rule of life in Indonesia is: There is no rule.
~3 Kilometers
The vendors thinned out considerably, replaced by growing numbers of Anies supporters. Then we came upon the root of the backup: cars had parked on the main road! The main road is a four-lane affair, two in each direction and divided by the massive cement supports of an overpass. The two lanes heading towards JIS were full of parked cars and SUVS. Motors had parked perpendicular, their rear tires in the narrow shoulder and their front tires on the sidewalk. An entire two rows of motors had also parked in the divider between opposing lanes.
This time was about 7:30am. Edder checked his phone.
“My friends inside said that the parking lot was full, so they started parking on the streets around JIS.”
“Is that legal?!”
He shrugged. “No, of course not. But the police can’t fine everyone.”
“Okay… so are they still taking in people in JIS?”
“They ran out of seats awhile back. Standing room only. But they’re still taking people.”
“Do you want to keep going?”
Edder philosophically puffed his vape and shrugged. “Yeah, why not?”
~2.5 Kilometers
The main road at the 3 kilometer mark was overloaded with parked cars, parked motors, and groups of people shuffling in between. Edder and I were caught in the riptide of humanity, swept inexorably away from the safety of the edges and carried towards JIS. We shuffled forward the next half kilometer at a snail’s pace.
Taxi drivers slept in their cars, engines on idle to keep the AC switched on. More economically-minded drivers turned off their cars and opened the windows. Between the hot sun and the sheer amount of humanity, those cars became large mobile ovens with cross-ventilation. Their drivers were certainly roasting in their own juices.
It was now 8:30 in the morning and the sun was out in full force. The crowd became densely packed as we walked. We could only shuffle forward about 12 inches per step. The air was hot and thick with humidity and dust. Undercurrents of sweaty, unwashed humanity, errant car fumes, and a polluted river hung in the air. Maybe the resultant miasma caused my mind a moment of panic. I thought that Edder and I would surely die if the crowd stampeded. We would simply be trampled into paste, caught as we were in the middle of this ocean of humanity. In the best alternative, we would be pushed into the dirty river and then slowly waste away from pollution or mutant brain-eating amoebas. I was ready to wave the white flag. I just needed a good reason to do it.
“Edder, are the gates still open? Are they still taking people?”
He sent a Whatsapp to his friends who were smart enough to arrive at 3am. “They said the gates have been closed. They’re not taking anyone else”.
That was that. “Edder, my man, I’m sorry… I think I’m done.”
“You want to stop?”
“Yeah… if they’ve closed the gates there’s no real point, right?”
“I suppose so. Okay we’ll stop.”
It was clear we had no way to simply turn around or even eventually shift towards the edge. The tide deposited us on the concrete divider between the opposing lanes. It was full of parked motorbikes. Edder sat on one and motioned me to sit on another.
“These aren’t our motorbikes!”
“Yeah it’s okay. Even if they did care, they have no way to kick us off.”
Logical. Also, I was damn tired. I sat down. “So now what?”
“Well, if I was by myself I’d just keep going because we’re so close. But I guess we’ll just wait till we can walk back. Hopefully we can get on my bike and go back home.”
“But the gates are closed… how would you get in even if you got there?”
Edder shrugged. “Getting in isn’t that hard.”
Ah, sorry man. You can go on ahead without me if you want. I won’t be offended”.
“Nah, it’s okay. You’re old; we’ve got to look out for your health!”
“Thanks for looking out for grandpa.”
8:30am-9:00am
A group of young men passed wearing white tees that said, “Wakanda No More, Indonesia Forever!” I had seen those around but had no clue how the fictional African kingdom was tied to Indonesia. Or of said fictional African Kingdom’s sudden demise. Edder laughed. “So a lot of people were talking about Indonesia’s problems on the internet, but you know the new law about criminalizing criticism of the government… so instead of using ‘Indonesia’ they called it ‘Wakanda’. Anies promised that he will allow free speech if he becomes president. So he said that [pointing to the shirts].” I nodded my head in appreciation of Indonesian netizens’ ingenuity.
After them came a crowd of men and women wearing tees representing the hardline Muslim political parties. “Interesting that the hardliners show up also. I thought Anies was supposedly moderate? Like he’s not going to push for syariah law?”
“He is moderate… but Prabowo and Ganjar are secular Muslims.”
“Something is better than nothing, huh?”
“Ehh… something like that.” Edder took another philosophically slow draw from his vape.
The hardliners began to chant Sholawat Nabi (one of many prayer chants). Perhaps they wanted to encourage the masses of Islamic faithful as they tiredly shuffled to JIS. We sat on our respective motorbikes owned by other people and listened in silence for a few cycles. It was beautiful to listen to, though I’m not sure it energized the masses. They certainly could not have moved faster if they were.
Then came an extended golf cart with side-seating, 20+ ladies in matching white and navy blue hijabs with matching bags. They had managed to stay in their vehicle by traveling up the opposing lane. Every lady smiled serenely and chatted with her neighbor as their vehicle slowly crawled towards JIS.
I wondered what would have happened if there were cars leaving JIS. It was rather a moot point. All four lanes were equally full of pedestrians heading to JIS. I also supposed that the crowds already there were so thick that whoever tried to leave would most likely surrender to inertia. Much like us.
9:00am - 9:30am
The masses grew into a dense, nigh impenetrable, but fluid mass that inexorably plodded in one direction. I supposed that no one else had friends on the inside to tell them that the lot was full and the gates were closed. Or maybe they didn’t care. Support by proximity was good enough.
An ambulance crawled up the opposing traffic lane about fifteen minutes after the luxury golf cart. The driver turned on his lights and half-heartedly twittered his siren after he stopped making headway. The crowd did not (or could not) make way. The ambulance driver turned onto a side road, backed into the main street, and reversed its course. That is, it started down the same street in the correct orientation and proceeded counter-flow to Anies’ faithful thousands. I hoped the ambulance was not actually necessary. Medical emergency from panicked trampling or heat exhaustion were distinct possibilities.
Loud shouting around us brought me up from my morbid musings.
“Whom for President?!” [*direct translations]
“a-NIES!”
“Whom for President?!”
“a-NIES!”
“a-NIES!”
“Presi-DENT!”
“a-NIES!”
“Presi-DENT!”
“No to magic corn!”
“a-NIES!”
“No to magic corn!”
“a-NIES!”
That caught me off guard. Edder laughed. “One of Prabowo’s platforms was food sustainability in Indonesia. He planted all this cassava in Kalimantan, but it turned out the soil was no good for cassava. So they planted corn instead. One of Prabowo’s opponents joked that the corn was magical. The government wasted a lot of money on that.”
“Whom for President?!”
“a-NIES!”
“a-NIES!”
“Presi-DENT!”
“Who is handsome?!”
“a-NIES!”
“Who is handsome?!”
“a-NIES!”
I couldn’t help but laugh. Edder laughed and shrugged. Maybe the crowd rouser had run out of ammo and desperately started throwing out whatever “would stick”. The crowd didn’t seem to mind. I personally felt Anies’ opponent Ganjar was better looking, but what do I know? The rouser moved on past us, shouting slogans swallowed up by the bodies and increasing distance.
Somewhere around this time, an expat friend who had lived in the country for years messaged me and asked what I was up to on this fine weekend morning. I told her I was trying to go to Anies’ rally. She responded, “What?! You need to get out of there, Josh, right now!”
“I’m not there. We gave up awhile ago; we’re just trapped.”
“Well leave when you can. And if anyone asks you about politics, don’t answer.”
“I’m a safe bet since I don’t know anything anyway.”
“Well don’t say anything to anyone! And leave when you can.”
I was a bit confused but not at all worried. No one seemed interested in anything I had to say so far. By 9:30am the crowd had thinned out enough. We hopped off the bikes and wiped away any evidence of our presence. We walked perpendicular the current and landed ourselves on the sidewalk, which was by now mostly empty.
10:00am - The Bitter End
The walk back was thankfully and relatively quick. All the occupied taxis we passed on the way in were still there in the same state, engines on idle or parked with the windows down. The vendors still hawked their wares. Edder’s bike was still blocked by the solid crush of humanity walking the street.
“So!!….. mmmm… want to walk to starbucks and wait a bit longer?”
“Eh…. okay. It seems the nearest is Ancol. But you have to pay to get in. Is that alright?”
“Sure.” After all, I was responsible for his stranding. It was clear that without me he would have joined the crush in JIS and slowly lost oxygen and/or consciousness as he raised lusty cheers for the presidential hopeful. I’d also proposed our after-party for two. I would be an ungrateful senior citizen to not pay for his entry and drink.
Twenty minutes later, we walked into Ancol through the motorway entrance. I paid an indecent amount of money for both of us to enter. Then we sat down in Starbucks Ancol. Over the course of two hours we met: (a) a family who feared they would miss their flight because they could not bypass the politically-active masses between them and the airport; (b) two families who also gave up supporting Anies at JIS; and (c) several old Chinese men on a coffee klatsch. We ourselves drank coffee and talked about Trump and Biden because the only thing more amusing than Indonesian politics is American politics.
At 12:00pm, Edder decided to walk to his bike and head home. He ended up hiring a Gojek driver instead. He would have to hire a gojek driver to return to his bike later at night.
Thus my attempt to experience a slice of Indonesian politics ended before it began. My political curiosity was choked out by high heat and humidity, low mobility, fear of trampling, and my own lack of personal stake in the matter. It had first sprinted, then crawled, and slowly expired by imaginary trampling about 2.5 kilometers from the finish line. We almost reached the end. It was almost fun.
Coda
I later asked my friend why she was so alarmed that I was at the campaign. She replied, “My husband attended Jokowi’s campaign rally when he was running for president. He replied in what we both thought was a very balanced way about Jokowi’s campaign. Then the news media took it apart and accused him of trying to influence Indonesian politics!”
I felt her worries for me were well-founded but a bit overblown. First, I wouldn’t have anything helpful or detrimental to say because I didn’t know anything. Second, I could always hide behind my language skills, which were almost proficient but not quite. Lastly, and most importantly, I’m not Bule (White), unlike my friend and her husband. The simple truth is that I’m not shiny enough to pay attention to no matter how much American-ness I ooze.